Here’s a curated list of seven standout pizza joints in and around Westlake Village, CA—each offering its own vibe, slice style, and local following. Whether you're grabbing lunch with friends, watching football, or heading out for a cozy date-night pie, these spots hit the mark.
1. Made in Italy Bistro
4.7•Italian restaurant
Why it stands out:
-
This place specializes in Neapolitan-style pizza and handmade pasta, using fresh, simple ingredients and recipes passed down through generations. Made in Italy Bistro
-
Owned by a husband-and-wife chef team, it has an intimate “from-scratch” vibe—with a nod to Italy in its décor and food.
-
Located at 3825 E Thousand Oaks Blvd, this is a solid pick for a true sit-down Italian pizza experience in Westlake Village.
Tip: Go for one of their wood-fired pies and maybe indulge in their handmade pasta to extend the meal beyond just pizza.
2. Freda’s Pizza Kitchen
4.6•Pizza restaurant
Why it stands out:
-
Located at 3835 E Thousand Oaks Blvd Suite A2. fredaspizza.com
-
Designed for casual dining—perfect for families or groups who want a straightforward pizza place (with good reviews).
-
One Redditor locally noted:
“Freda’s is good too.” Reddit
This kind of endorsement from local community threads adds nice credibility.
Exterior and delicious pizza pies from Freda’s Pizza — known for NY-style and creative toppings in Westlake Village.
Tip: If you’re looking for something more relaxed (less formal than a sit-down bistro), this might be it—especially for take-out or group meals.
3. Prince St. Pizza
4.3•Pizza restaurant
Why it stands out:
-
Located at 30768 Russell Ranch Rd, Westlake Village. locations.princestreetpizza.com
-
A grab-and-go vibe with pickup, delivery, and late night options—good for pizza on the move or quick stop-in. l
-
For those who like their pizza more casual (think slice & take away) and not necessarily full formal dining, this is a strong choice.
Tip: Ideal if you’re stopping by after something nearby (shopping, errands) and want a quality pizza without a long sit-down time.
4. Parma Pizzeria Napoletana (in nearby Thousand Oaks)
Why it's worth the short drive:
-
Located at 796 Thousand Oaks Blvd, Thousand Oaks—just a short hop from Westlake Village. PARMAS PIZZERIA
-
Known for both Detroit-style (thicker crust, caramelized cheese edges) and New York-style (thin, foldable) pizzas, giving you two strong styles in one place.
-
The rock & roll aesthetic and family-run vibe add personality.
Tip: If you're willing to venture just a little beyond Westlake Village, this place gives you excellent variety and a slightly different pizza experience.
5. Slice House by Tony Gemignani
Why it stands out:
-
Located at 3297 E Thousand Oaks Blvd., Thousand Oaks — right near the edge of Westlake Village. locations.slicehouse.com
-
Helmed by 13-time world pizza champion Tony Gemignani. They offer a diverse menu of New York-style, Detroit-style, Grandma-style, and Sicilian-style pizzas. And they fed the firefighters during the Palisades fire.
-
A nice choice if you want a slice (or several styles) rather than just one kind of pie.
Tip: If you want to mix and match styles (e.g., one Detroit-thicker crust + one foldable New York slice), this is your spot.
6. D’Amore’s Pizza - Tina's Favorite!
4.8•Pizza restaurant
Why it stands out:
-
Address: 2869 E Thousand Oaks Blvd., Thousand Oaks, CA 91362.
-
Known for thin-crust, East-coast-style pizza and BY-the-slice options. One reviewer noted:
“Great pizza and pasta… the pizza isn’t greasy or heavy.”
"Excellent crust! So yummy I ate two HUGE slices!"
-
They also offer gluten-free and dairy-free pizza options. allthingsmalibu.com
Tip: If you're picking up and want something a little lighter or easier to fold/take out, D’Amore’s is a solid choice.
7. Farfalla Trattoria
4.3•Italian restaurant
Casual Italian with Wood-Fired Pizzas 🍕
Located in The Promenade at Westlake Village, Farfalla Trattoria is a cozy Italian restaurant known for its warm ambiance and classic Italian menu that includes wood-fired pizzas alongside pastas, salads, and small plates — perfect for a sit-down meal with family or friends.
🍕 Why It’s Worth Trying
-
Authentic Italian fare with a variety of pizza options that pair nicely with their wine list and cocktails — ideal for a leisurely dinner. Trattoria Farfalla
-
Sit-down experience: Great choice if you want a full meal rather than just a quick slice.
-
Lunch & dinner: Pizzas are available alongside appetizers, pastas, and salads for varied dining.
Tip: Go here when you’re in the mood for a relaxed, Italian pizza night with other menu options to explore.
🍕 Final Thoughts
Westlake Village and its neighboring communities offer an impressively diverse pizza scene—whether you’re craving a quick slice, a casual family dinner, or a polished Italian night out. If you’re after a classic sit-down experience with wine and ambiance, Farfalla Trattoria and Made In Italy Bistro deliver beautifully crafted, wood-fired pizzas alongside full Italian menus. For reliable, local comfort, Freda’s Pizza Kitchen remains a neighborhood favorite.
When speed and variety matter, Slice House by Tony Gemignani is the go-to for pizza by the slice across multiple styles, while Prince Street Pizza nails the grab-and-go craving. And for those who love thin-crust, East Coast–style pies, D’Amore’s Pizza is well worth the short drive.
Bottom line: whether you’re dining lakeside, ordering in for movie night, or chasing the perfect slice, there’s a standout pizza spot nearby to match every mood—and every appetite—in and around Westlake Village.
